latest

Discussion board assignments lack meaningful discussion

By: AJ Bonilla, Staff Photographer

I’m someone who enjoys a good discussion board post assignment —  emphasis on good because most are not. 

If you’re unfamiliar with discussion board posts, they operate like a forum where a professor prompts the class to answer a question. Once you’ve answered it, you’re also more than likely going to be required to respond to two other classmates’ answers so that the post becomes a “discussion.” 

Essentially, it’s a graded conversation that tends to feel forced and bothersome.

Unfortunately, whether you find yourself participating in a good discussion board assignment is up to the teacher, the type of classmates you have and lady luck herself. 

The two-reply mandate means that most posts end up including the same type of response we’ve all heard before: “Great point, I completely agree with you, I especially loved when you said this, I said that too. Thanks for sharing!” 

It’s worse when the question at the center of the discussion is objective rather than subjective. If there’s only one answer, you find it, you answer it, and so does everyone else. What else is to be said? 

What's even worse is reading through the discussion board and realizing that 85-95% of the posts or the responses are clearly AI-generated. 

I get that we all, on some level, get a bad taste in our mouths when we hear the words “discussion board post,” but is it really so bad that people can’t just find the will to answer a question on their own?

On the opposite side of the spectrum, it can be so frustrating to put in the time and effort to remain genuine with your thoughts and your words only to see your peers don’t even take the time to proofread what AI gave them. I’ve literally seen people accidentally include in their contributions the part of the ChatGPT response asking if anything needs to be changed for the assignment.

Part of the reason we find discussion board posts so useless is because of how we respond to each other. We forget to find time to acknowledge it as an opportunity to actually share our thoughts or engage with another classmate.

 Teachers who post these kinds of assignments should consider whether they are perpetuating the use of AI in assignments by forcing requirements that are nonsensical. If a student can genuinely and earnestly answer the question completely, concisely and thoroughly in 250 words, why make them bloat their thoughts to 500 or even 1,000 words?

But the teachers aren't always to blame. When handed a genuine opportunity to have a discussion, most students will refuse to see it as an opportunity and assign themselves the mental load of disliking something before they’ve even tried it. Of all the discussion board posts I’ve done, I can recall enjoying only the ones in my art appreciation class, and that’s because art appreciation is inherently subjective. Discussion boards must be asking subjective questions if they are to work properly. 

Another problem: Most of the time, it seems, people don’t start the discussion board assignment until the night before it’s due, meaning they blow up everyone's Canvas notifications at 11 p.m. Other students are only able to finish the two-response part of the assignment once those posts have come in, and late at night the day before the assignment is due, none of us have the energy to come up with a genuine response. It only reinforces how little we actually want to engage with discussion. 

At the end of the day, the biggest problem is that students see discussion board posts for what they are. Our brains categorize them as something to check off the list of assignments or something we want to procrastinate until the last minute rather than as a spontaneous, enjoyable conversation. 

And in the age of AI, it’s becoming harder and harder to mentally assign value to something that AI could do for you, especially when good discussions rarely actually materialize from these assignments. 

It really is a dice roll because even if all the stars align for a genuine discussion and your professor isn't forcing but rather is facilitating discussion, do you or the people around you even want to have it?

PHOTO: AJ Bonilla, Staff Photographer